Problematic Tangents

2009

 
 

Teachers’ initial exposure to different types of technology and the possibilities of utilizing that technology in the composition classroom often preclude a critical vision of how to incorporate those technologies. As excitement builds, and teachers attempt to include multimodal writing assignments or uses of new and different programs and hardware, classroom goals and objectives may flounder and deteriorate. Lenard (2007), for example, cautions that high expectations for new assignments may ultimately occlude the technological difficulties students face in using the new technology. Additionally, high expectations of the technology may enable some students’ hegemonic views to be foisted on others students during the class’s acclimation to the new technology and assignments (Lenard, p. 78). Lenard, for instance, discusses students who use multimodal assignments like blogging and commenting to attack openly gay or other minority students in the classroom. As Lundin (2008) suggests, even when technology does not silence minority voices, incorporating contemporary technologies into the classroom may be a waste of time to some instructors and teachers, with little carry over to course objectives. In these instances, technology has not been properly incorporated into the classroom. The instructor is not aware of the tools’ potential or problems, and does not properly introduce them or their possible uses to the class (Rice, 2008).

Bringing Multimodality into the Composition Classroom

“Portfolios are not an appendix, something tacked onto the tail end of classroom curriculum” (Murphy & Smith, 1999, p. 328).

There are a number of problems associated with bringing multimodal assignments and tools, as well as portfolios, into the composition classroom. I have added a series of “Tangents” pages to explain some of this. Please refer to Tangent# pages for discussions of problematic portfolios as well as problematic intersections. Sometimes, the perpendicular line drawn between portfolios and multimodal composition leads teachers and students to tangent lines branching from particular intersections. My tangent pages are meant to address these issues.