|
![]() |
Index |
![]() |
Editorial Staff |
![]() |
Submissions |
![]() |
Resources |
![]() |
Archives |
![]() |
This is familiar ground to anyone who accepts Hawisher's and Selfe's (1993) hypothesis that we live in "prefigurative" times. Faigley (1992) once watched as a group of his students, writing under pseudonyms, turned a reading discussion into a flame-war; he believed he was witnessing "the dance of death upon the graves of the old narratives of moral order" (p. 196). These are difficult claims to challenge, but they can be qualified. Our elders may not have considered the consequences of environmental depredation on a global scale, nuclear or biological terrorism, or hackers lurking like ghosts in the machine of electronic global commerce. But those before us faced, in their own ways, other challenges, even terrors as the moral order of society wavered, even disintegrated around them. A neighbor's Ike-era fallout shelter reminds me of this, as well as family stories about the influenza epidemic of 1919 and the collapse of the economy a decade later. The dance of death remains the same, even if the steps change. Our elders also lived in prefigurative times; any era with an Auschwitz would be without remembered precedent. As Sidra Ezrahi DeKoven (1980) reminds us, the reality of the extermination camps was beyond the capacity of language as it existed then. Despite the limitation, writers of works about the Holocaust somehow forged ahead into literary terra incognita by representing "an oscillation and a struggle between continuity and discontinuity with the cultural as well as the historical past" (DeKoven, 1980, p. 4). One does not read Holocaust Literature for pleasure. Still, the success of those writers in responding to unprecedented events always provides me with a sobering dose of reality when theory-driven worries about our era crowd around me. Instead of fretting or refusing "it," we might instead search for an oscillation between past and present today. And the very books that students sell back might be one of their best resources as we teach them about that oscillation, if we can challenge them to become engaged in the tasks--and joys--of reading difficult texts and responding to them.To those ends, conferencing helped me to establish oscillations between past and present, between reader and text. |