Reflection in the Electronic Writing Classroom

L. Lennie Irvin, San Antonio College

 

Examples of Mid-Term Constructive Reflection--"in and amongst the drafts"

from the Learning Record Online

Student 1 --click on the B.1 Midterm Summary and C.1 Midterm Evaluation links
Student 2--B.1 Midterm Summary and C.1 Midterm Evaluation

 

from my own Freshman Composition I students

Mid-Term Reflection Topic and Instructions:

We have made it half way through our journey together (I can hardly believe it!). It is a good time to stop and take a break. It is a good time to think about where we’ve been and what we’ve done, where we are and what we are doing, where we are going and what we will do.

Topic:
In this writing class, what have you learned?
What do you believe you still need to work on more?
How/can you use what you have learned in other contexts?

I have two requests as you write:
1) Please write something substantial and well-considered (roughly 350-500 words).
2) Please refer to and point directly to pieces of writing you have done.

Debra's Mid-Term Reflections:

In this class, so far, I have practiced my writing skills continuously with the process and free writing journals. I have found that this practice and thinking of a topic to write my free writing journals about has helped me with my brainstorming problem and my writer's block. I also get great ideas for my novel, mentioned in previous assignments, while I'm writing these journals. The ideas do not always have anything to do with the journal topic at all, but I find that while my creative juices are flowing for the journals that I get the same affect as right before you go to bed when you get all those great ideas but don't want to get out of bed to write them down. Of coarse then, in the morning, you can't remember what you were thinking the night before. I just hate it when that happens. The wonderful thing about thinking of these things while writing the journals instead is that I already have out paper, I already have out pencil, and the thought doesn't get away from me before I write it down. That has truly helped me.

However, I still need to work on expanding my explanations and descriptions. Another thing that I am still struggling with and have been for a very long time is punctuation. The way I tell if something is punctuated correctly is I say it out loud and where there's a breath I put in a comma or apostrophe. I used to think that this was a fool-proof way of doing this, but I have found that things are not always correct written the way they sound when spoken. One reason for this is that when I speak in real life I often use improper conjugations that change the way a sentence is arranged. This throws off my writing a bit. I need to work on knowing from knowledge what goes where so I don't have to worry about whether or not my spoken language is correct.

I have learned a great deal about the power of description. I have been able to apply this usefully already by going back and adding several powerful scenes in my book. I went back and read it after making these additions and it improved the flow and texture of the novel immensely. I also put to practical use the thinking from the audience's point of view method that we learned. It seems like such a simple tip, but, in the past, I have always written for myself and so never really thought of it. Before we were taught this I never had anyone read my book to make suggestions so I never knew that I was using mixed metaphors that only I and my best friend understood. Now I actually try to become someone else to write. This also gives me a fresh new perspective for even more story ideas. Those are my practical applications for these skills outside of this class. I hope to learn much more that I can apply later on as well.

 

Peter's Mid-Term Reflection

This class this year has done so much for me. But the main thing that this class has done for me is help develop a new writing sense. As I have written essays and have gotten peer responses back from others, I have learned more on how to think as I write. I have trouble so many times with just writing what is on my mind, but I never come to the realization that to others, it makes absolutely no sense, or it does not have a clear point. One essay that helped in this aspect was the Reader and Writers essay. As I read my peers suggestions on what they liked to read, it became the beginning of a new thought process I was to go through. Another essay that helped in developing this writer sense was our family stories. As I finished "Two Pole," my paper was critiqued and responded to by my peers. This was probably one of the most influential essay's that we wrote. Thinking of the story was fairly easy, but it became a little more difficult when we were forced to show and not tell what we wanted to get across. As I adjusted my paper according to the need of my peers, I began to notice that my point was a little more clear and I attracted my audience a little better. I have not even come close to being perfect, but I still have so much more to learn. The main thing that I have to continue to learn is how to think of a way to attract my audience and also to narrow my audience down. In my proverb paper, "Hope for the Best, but Prepare for the Worst", I was informed that my audience was too broad. This is a huge problem that can be easily fixed, I just have to think about the exact audience I am trying to reach. All of these things I have learned, I plan to use in every paper that I write, whether it is a letter to a friend or a petition for a specific audience. Even the little things, like to make sure my quotation marks are after the period, I will use to further advance my writing skills in days to come. I believe that writing only gets better when you practice, and that's why I think that we are all collectively getting better as a class in our writing ablilities.

Anessa's Mid-Term Reflection

This was a great writing class. It was not what I expected, but it was very intresting. When I went to talk to a counselor in the Woman's Center, she had told me that this was an intensive writing course. To me that meant a ton of writing assignments. I was glad to see it was on the computer. It was very intresting to use the Moo. I enjoyed posting my writings, reading my classmates, and the peer response.
In this class I've learned that it takes revision after revision to come up with a wonderful paper. That I should not be hard on myself in the first writing I do. It is more like the free writing we did. This , free writing, was a great new tool. I can not recall having done that in the past as a way of preparation to write a paper. This was definitely a gift. It has helped in other areas of study as well. In the class I also learned not to be afraid. Just put it on paper in a rough form and then polish it over and over. I also got to go back and get a short refresher course on punctiation and sentence structre.

This is also still my weak point. I need to continually go over and practice sentence structure and puncuation. I would like to use the semi-colon right and more, the hypen, and the colon. I also need to learn more about writing papers. How to come in with the strong introduction, a supportive body, and a great closing to wrap the paper all together. I need to learn to be descriptive in all my writings. I believe this will help the reader get a much clearer picture or see my point in a much better light. In order to be good at description, I think, a bigger variety of words. This will also help to enhance my writing skills.
As I stated before, I use the free writing to do other assignments. In my Philosophy and Psychology classes I free write to get all the information about the chapters we went over down and see what I need to know and to see what it is I do know. When it is put down on paper, for me, it helps me to absorb it better. Me free writing helps also when you are preparing an essay to try and receive a scholarship. I get what I want to say down and then I can go back and organize and polish my thoughts up. It also can help when writing any form of letter to a professional person. Just to put all thoughts, in order, on a paper is hard to do. So I am glad to have learned this simple technique to write important papers.

 

 

 

 

 

   
Introduction | The Importance of Reflection | Reflection as a Catalyst | Reflection in the Writing Classroom | Reflection in the E-Writing Classroom | Reflection as Observation | Reflection as Refraction | Reflection as Coherence | Conclusion | Works Cited
by L. Lennie Irvin, San Antonio College